Of all M.M.P. elections, the 2017 edition is probably the most controversial so far (Stuff)

In contrast with the 2026 New Zealand election, other M.M.P. elections have been comparatively clear cut. In this article I look at the progression of them from the first in 1996, through to 2023.

The first election in 1996 was clean. Although it took nine weeks to result in a Government forming, there was no overhang. That collapsed in August 1998 when National decided to sell Wellington Airport, something it had promised not to.

In 1999, a trend that has become a defining characteristic of M.M.P. elections became clear: 3-terms maximum. National – 1990-1999 – was ejected from office by New Zealanders who decided it was time for another party to make the mistakes – and own them.

The 5th Labour Government

The first term of Prime Minister Helen Clark was in the pre-September 11 foreign policy climate. It had a host of smaller problems to deal with, like a lacklustre economy, the widening rift between the haves and have nots – problems that exist to this day.

The 2002 election, with “Sandpaper Gate” and “Paintergate” controversies, seemed to not harm Labours popularity. It swept back into power with 3 extra M.P.’s. Confidence and supply agreements were negotiated with United Future and the Greens to make up the numbers. Reforms included R.M.A reform, the Terrorism Suppression Act and the introduction of N.C.E.A.

After 3 M.M.P. elections, voters were beginning to sour on Labour. National’s conservative wing, revived by Dr Don Brash saying that the nuclear legislation would be gone by lunchtime. Dr Brash further stirred the hornets nest with commentary about women, and questioning the Treaty of Waitangi. Unfortunately for National, it turned the female and Maori vote against him.

As Prime Minister Helen Clarks third and final term progressed, Dr Brash resigned. He was replaced by the young and charismatic John Key. His more moderate views won back much of the support Dr Brash lost.

The 5th National Government

National Party victories in 2008, 2011 and 2014 by centre-right leader John Key all retained the A.C.T. Party and United Future. The 2008 election was won after a public, dissatisfied with Labour’s refusal to grant significant fiscal relief, voted Labour out. To be fair, Labour was at the end of a third term. M.M.P. has thus far denied anyone the right to form a 4th term Government. The only instances prior to M.M.P. elections were during World War 2, and the government of Keith Holyoake (1960-1972).

Around that time “Dirty Politics” – a play on the Nicky Hager book by the same name – began to influence the election. Elections began to become less of a contest of ideas. They became more about which party or faction could find the most toxic mud to sling at the other. Whilst it was not unprecedented prior to these particular M.M.P. elections, the change in tenor became notable.

The hey day of John Key

In 2011 National was handed 47% of Parliament, equating to 59 seats. This was despite the 5 seat caucus A.C.T. had in 2008, being cut down to 1 in 2011 due to public anger over disgraceful conduct by former M.P. David Garrett. Mr Garrett was initially lauded on the right for his 3 Strikes legislation, styled on similar policies employed in the United States. It turned out that Mr Garrett had stolen the identity of a dead child to use in a passport application.

The 2014 election was lost by Labour. This was perhaps in large part because its then Leader David Cunliffe declared he was embarrassed to be a man. That statement lost Labour huge support among the male population. National was returned to office with 47% of the seats. It was enabled by supply and confidence agreements with United Future, A.C.T. and Te Pati Maori. The only party in Opposition to grow in 2014 was actually New Zealand First.

The 6th Labour Government

In 2017, something unusual happened. When the initial election results came out, everyone was expecting National to have achieved something truly historic: a fourth term in office. It had 56 seats in Parliament, as opposed to Labour’s 45. It was clear cut the largest party in Parliament. However, due to “political baggage”, New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters decided Labour was a safer bet.

The 2020 General Election saw Labour getting returned to power with 65 seats in a 120 seat Parliament. This ensured that forming a new Government was straight forward. It was made possible by Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s leadership on COVID. Clear communication, an attempt to empathize with everyone affected. Then a clear plan to revive the economy post-lockdown. What more could you ask for?

The toxicity and influence of external actors in M.M.P. elections took a clear turn for the worse in 2023. The right, stung by Ms Ardern’s leadership on COVID-19 and being infiltrated by conspiracy theorists, had undergone a sea change. Gone was any sense of moderate policy making, such as that which defined the prior Governments. Astroturf groups connected to Atlas Network, such as the Taxpayers Union and Hobsons Pledge, appeared. Gone was any respect for bipartisanship on common issues such as Treaty of Waitangi. Some say a surge in Pentecostal Christians in the National Party also had a role. I am not going to comment on that. I will acknowledge a generally more prominent conservative Christian nationalist fringe is now present.

For the first time in M.M.P. elections, in 2026, concerns have been raised about the transparency of the election process. But that, as an evolving story, is for another day…


Discover more from Leftist Kiwi Writes

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

What's your spin?